If Joe C. would, have fought James Toney, who would win?

considering toney was fighting at cruiser by the time joe collected the WBO strap i go for toney by stinkface.

 

Calzaghe UD.

 

the only super middle that beats joe in his prime is roy jones and that would be a good fight, i pick joe over hopkins and toney in their primes,

joe c by ud

 

Calzaghe UD

 

Toney UD, and a very comfortable one to, probably by at least 3 rounds.

 

toney would probably bloody calzaghe.

 

Toney is, excuse me, was a better fighter than Calzaghe is. He would win, he is stronger and more powerful, has a good chin. He catches Calzaghe, because Calzaghe leaves himself open throwing so many punches.

 

What about a pre 1993 Michael Nunn VS Joe C?

 

Toney Ud or late TKO. Too much skill

 

Lights Out!

 

calzaghe by UD!

 

A no brainer JOE CALZAGHE..:yep

 

Even though I'm pretty much a Calzaghe 'hugger, I've got to go for Toney UD12.

 

Toney was/is a fantastically skilled fighter. The old version that doesn't throw punches would struggle but you wouldn't catch Calzaghe at heavyweight anyway. Toney at 160-168 would put on a clinic, Joe isn't exactly elusive....Toney UD.