is any former p4p#1 not on your atg list?

Any boxer that was never top10 p4p that can be considered ATG?

Other than SNV?

 

Hmm.. Dont think so. Imo the weakest p4p #1 was probably Shane Mosley (no hate or anything as I still think he's great).

I mean on a list where there's names like
Pac
May
Jones jr
Chavez
Leonard
Hearns
Hagler
De La Hoya
Hopkins
Whitaker
Tyson
and Duran.. You have to say Mosley was the weakest of them. Still impressive though.

 

Mosley and De La Hoya aren't top 50 ATG

 

Depends how many ATGs you allow..

 

Don Curry

 

May cant possibly be ATG. That's just too much fanboyism there, he cant punch for ****, defend yes, punch hell no.

 

*Troll detected*

 

Really? Lets see his last fights.

1. Against part-time boxer DLH, Floyd only landed a few meaningful punches.
2. Against 50-loss Baldo, Floyd never landed a strong punch. That was for the whole 12 rounds.
3. Against the much smaller fighter Marquez, who while small was also fat as ****, he never hurt him, the equivalent of Pac not hurting Calderon in any way.
4. Against Mosley without PEDS, he also didnt impress much.

I'm the troll? Fukk you.

 

No wonder Nazim Richardson was threatening to stop the fight atsch, did he threaten to stop the fight against Pacquiao? :think

 

*******s and *****s are equal to trolls..

 

Because he was trying to motivate Shane Mosley to Step up and Win the fight.

Against Pac, they'd given up from the opening bell

 

Shane Mosley was p4p#1, and he is not an ATG IMO.

I can't think of any ATG who would never have been p4p ranked though. I'll have a think, but I seriously doubt it.

 

Poor Shane :-(