Who would have won? Judah or Mosley?

I mean, how does Zab win this? Even with Shane being shot?

By picking up more rounds? No. Shane outworks him by oodles, and will have the front-runner faded from trying to keep up by the quarter-way mark.

Knockout? Shane is maybe the one guy that could literally laugh off those left uppercuts. Hell, he could give Zab three minutes of freebies and probably keep his legs.

 

Why don't I remember this? Would've been a good fight.

 

Probably because it's only one of dozens upon dozens of cocktease matches that get made and then scrapped (just in the last few years).

 

Mosley by savage beating.

 

Mosley easily. While Judah is probably more skilled technically, he lost to fighters I think he was way better than. Everyone knows Judah cracks under pressure and Shane would be putting him under pressure all night. Remember, this is 2009 Shane.

 

I'd love to see a public poll on this. :yep





The punishment that would be inflicted on those picking Judah. :thedevil1

 

Judah gets the early lead. He's a good boxer and Mosley has a history of trubbel with good boxers. However, Judah is also known to fade late and has been stopped. I think this either ends up as a ko win in the late rounds for Mosley or a close decision that would likely favor Mosley, but could go either way.

 

Mosley would have beat him after a rough start. Zab would fade late and Shane is always a good finisher when he has the opponent at a disadvantage.

 

Pretty much this. :deal

 

Judah's early lead would cap off about a third of the way through.

8-4 is not a close decision.

Also, Judah is not a terribly good boxer. He's an OK boxer. He relies a lot more on his speed and athleticism than actual craft. In craft, they're probably on about even terms. Mosley would be at a speed disadvantage, but not as much of one as most of Judah's opponents...and he'd be far more active for Judah, and for far longer with his better stamina (even old).

 

why?? its boxing and anything can happen inside a ring ,and people are allowed an opinion. There are no certains in this sport thats why its great.

 

Mosley

 

You're right. It would be silly to ridicule anyone picking Judah in this match-up. :think

It would also be silly to ridicule anyone picking Bobby Pacquiao over Azumah Nelson prime for prime. Anything can happen in a boxing ring. :good

 

I say Mosely. Too strong willed for Judah... would be competitive for 6 rounds but Mosely would've stopped Zab late.

 

yep...kinda like and old shot to **** morales coming off a loss and looking old as hell then whoops pac ass,and then gettin smacked around by zahir raheem in his next fight or many people at the time claiming hatton was a protected euro bum and was gonna get crushed by tszyu. sometimes the better fighter loses.Tyson vs douglas ??? **** happens.