Marciano was very consistent but he may not have an advantage when compared with Dempsey in terms of the number of highly ranked contenders they...
Marciano's title defenses were against worthy contenders but to argue that he faced everyone is not correct since there were plenty of good...
Dempsey's inactivity after 1923 is irrelevant in a comparison with Marciano since Marciano faced top level competition for a shorter period of...
If Marciano was no longer ranked in the top 10 it would be because heavyweights had come along who accomplished more than he did rather than...
Holyfield clearly rates ahead of Bowe. There is no reasonable argument for rating Bowe ahead given his lack of accomplishments.
Rating Harry Wills ahead of Liston and Tyson seems perfectly reasonable. Although Tyson has many fans he was not the best heavyweight of his era...
Lewis was much closer to his peak when he fought Holyfield and Tyson than they were. I don't see how the age argument is relevant.
Louis and Lewis were good in their eras but like other small old timers they might not do well in modern times. Wladimir Klitschko would have...
Valdez was beaten by Hugo Corro shortly after the rematch with Monzon.
The junior lightweight, junior welterweight and junior middleweight classes are not legitimate. There is no point in having such weight classes....
Herbie Hide was not proven as a puncher against the division's elite. Hide would be a threat to guys in the top 40 or so but against the top 10...
Schmelling certainly accomplished more than Vitali but head to head it would not be surprising for Vitali to be superior. If they were in the...
Chris Byrd, John Ruiz, Wladimir Klitschko, Vitali Klitschko, Holyfield and Tua and even Jameel McCline would all likely all be favored to beat...
Holmes could rank above Johnson but the Ali fight does not help his legacy much if at all.
Golota was still young himself when he was blasted out by Lennox Lewis and ko'd by Michael Grant. Is Michael Grant one of Lewis's best opponnents...
