A lot of the replies to this thread seem to more correctly answer the question, 'What if X fighter was a bigger puncher'? Because, for example, if...
Note: "anywhere up to 168lb", not "Super-Middleweight." (Weigh in up to 168lb, same day. Approx. 50% resume, 50% H2H). 1. Greb 2. Fitzsimmons 3....
On my All-Time p4p list I have Olivares at #38 and Canelo #120. I'd say that's pretty accurate.
Two things: A. I probably overrate my favourites, now I think about it. B. I obviously like a fighter with a good story. 1. Sonny Liston 2....
Not dominant, but right up there with the best of them.
I actually have Tyson at 71 myself, so I can't really complain at 72! 71. Tyson 72. LaMotta 73. Hopkins etc...
Witherspoon by late stoppage.
Maybe something like this: 1. Bowe (41-0-0) 2. Fury (34-0-1) 3. W Klitschko (64-5) 4. V Klitschko (44-1) 5. Johnson (53-11-8) 6. Dempsey (53-6-8)...
Just about, for me. Something like this: 8. Tyson 9. Frazier 10. Usyk 11. Bowe
I have Ali a clear number 1. But then, I factor H2H more than most. I think there are very few who can beat Ali. I have Louis at a precarious...
25 to 30 seems about right to me. Great fighter.
Lewis by ref stoppage or KO in the first half of the fight.
I'm starting to think you're probably right. How would these two get on against, say, Galindez?
Thanks for the reply. While I am 100% sure that it is more logical to rank by weight class, it just doesn't seem right on a fair playing field to...
Sorry: 50% Resume - Who they did beat, when they themselves weighed in up to 175lb (not necessarily at LHW - could be at heavy or cruiser). 50%...
