You make excellent and articulate points, I am not necessarily disagreeing with you, I am just making counter points about why the win is not...
I also find hindsight frustrating, particularly if about a win of one of my favourite fighters. However I don't feel re-evaluating a match based...
" Thomas officially won only single rounds on two of the official cards but he made Tyson work" From an article which has a good breakdown of the...
I watched a bit of Pinky vs Witherspoon and Berbick, even between those two fights he seemed to be a diminished fighter and against Tyson he...
Toney was wildly inconsistent at MW but was the better fighter and IMO has by far the better wins at MW over Nunn and McCallum than Hopkins. To be...
Bloody hell this is a match no-one would want to see! Biggs had such a short time at the top that while I think he had much better skills unless...
I have no idea if Thomas was using again before this fight or if he was how much it effected him but I think Pinklon's drug issues are a factor in...
Similar fights, both at LMW with an ageing superstar taking on a solid younger champ. Of course Canelo has outshone Vasquez in his career overall...
I wonder if Monzon vs Napoles can provide some parallels in that a slick boxing WW (who started at LW and LWW) was simply ground down by a less...
Good points and to be fair if Sturm had got the nod over Oscar we would be thinking of him differently.
Without his eye trouble and if he came along a little bit later (and maybe taken an easier route) I see no reason he could not have fought for a...
Provocative post as always! IMO Floyd would struggle to repeat his easy win over Canelo at 160 as Alvarez had filled out and was more...
Interesting point re Spinks! Sturm I would not consider HOFer but Cotto, Canelo, Taylor yes of course. I forgot he beat Cotto actually! Don't know...
Nicky Piper vs Leeonzer Barber, I forgot about this one, I remember watching it live, go to about 38.26 in video. [MEDIA]
Inspired by @RJJFan interesting thread on Mayweather vs Barkley I wanted to ask which MW greats (ATG or HOF level) people feel Mayweather could...
