That's actually not a logically sound conclusion as they didn't ask people to rank their top 27. That a few rank Ibeabuchi in their top 10 and...
What makes McGrain's list so credible? It would be most interesting to hear his reasoning.
Somewhere around place 40 would seem low given that the Ingo - Patterson trilogy was very close. 1 clear victory each and the third fight having...
How much are those lists worth anyway? I saw that Foreman's top 10 list has Patterson at 6th for whatever that is worth. Liston didn't make top...
To me this is not a thread about ranking the top xx heavyweights champions ever. In any case, do you think that a higher ranked champion will...
Your score difference of 50-5 seems excessive as the gap wasn't that enormous. Or do you mean his record was 10x as good? I think the previous...
And Ingo punched harder than Liston according to Patterson. Could he hurt Liston? Surely. If not, Liston could not have been such a big puncher...
This is a terrible way to compare two fighters.
Ingo comfortably outboxed him and then you're talking about the last 10 seconds of his career :pancarta: Liston lost against Leotis Martin. Big deal?
Shows that the gap in their resumes is perhaps not as wide as you're claiming. If you think making that kind of list is a good way to determine...
Had they fought and Ingo would have won, you could easily argue that Ingo had the better career / was the better boxer. As it stands now, yes...
It's not the fights by themselves that I say is off but rather the scoring system. No doubt the result against Floyd was clearly superior for...
You also rate Folley highly and Cooper is getting a lot of criticism here. At least the version Ingo beat. Note that Cooper beat Folley just one...
Liston had a deeper resume but your list don't even give Ingo credit for the way he demolished Machen. You could also look at losses and Ingo wins...
Fair points but I think that solely using one opponent for comparison can be misleading. Patterson was just his perfect opponent may have made him...
