I would favor Walcott in a single match against any of the three, but were he to actually fight all three of them in a career, I think he would...
I agree that Dempsey doesn't belong in the top five. I have him substantially higher than you at #7, though I think he could reasonably be ranked...
Why, this is the strangest boxing match I've ever seen!
It's interesting that you and Janitor feel as though you never agree on anything, because I think of you both as guys I frequently agree with!
This fight seems to be quite polarizing in terms of scoring. I've never seen it myself.
Jack Johnson had quite the uppercut- look at the Ketchel knockout!
Far too strong and deep a talent pool for someone to truly dominate. Robinson might ultimately prove the top guy of the era, but I don't doubt...
I think Chuvalo would give Louis some awkward moments, but ultimately- with a ref from the last 75 years, anyway- I would expect Louis to get a...
Ding could beat Margarito.
On "LaMotta" and "honest" not belonging in the same sentence: have you read LaMotta's autobiography? He comes off as extremely honest there,...
While it is true that Walcott was only stopped by Louis and Marciano in the meaningful part of his career, it's worth pointing out that he was...
No, I really won't consider it terribly impressive for Peter to have beaten yet another extremely old, rusty and often-injured opponent, unless...
Archie Moore: 0-1 against Teddy Yarosz 0-1 against Charley Burley 4-1 against Jimmy Bivins 1-1 against Holman Williams 0-3 against Ezzard Charles...
We're talking IBHOF, right? Because there is also a lesser-known "World Boxing Hall of Fame." Assuming that is the case, Ezzard Charles was: 1-0...
You have a point, here... However, Monzon would still be at a considerable size and power deficit, and would at the least not enjoy the...
