I didn't see an A level performance against an aging JMM.:yep:think I guess you could call it A- if you'd like, but Pac fans will say that JMM's...
Can't say, the year is open. What I will say is that H2H wise, he will lose to several fighters at 135 and badly, now does that mean he's the best...
Entirely different scenerio. If Pac was actually a 3-1 underdog and David Diaz was actually a top fighter, regardless of names on resume, of...
No, I said that an A level performance can be made over a B- fighter, never did I say an A level performance automatically boosts you up in the...
Joseph? And I don't see a counter debate, I'll assume that I am at least in the logical area with it.:good
But I am not insisting that Calzaghe should be ranked P4P #1, I'd in fact argue against that. My posts are about a general point dealing with...
:lol::patsch Must not have seen Campbell-Juan Diaz, Juan Diaz proved immense more toughness in that fight vs. a much more lethal Nate Campbell....
Everybody who knows who Diaz was, knew he had no chance in hell of winning.
No he can be P4P #1, if you choose to rank him that way and most do, nobody will argue that and have a legitimate argument. But that is one type...
And if he does, he will recieve a bad loss, leaving these morons befuddled on what happened and why it happened. I'm not trying to bash Pac, but...
P4P #1 and 'the best fighter' in the world 'regardless of weight class' are the exact same thing? The P4P rating system is entirely efficient at...
:good Precisely. If all it takes to be P4P #1 is jumping up a division and defeating a 2nd tier level fighter like Diaz.:patsch But that brings...
I thought he already was P4P #1, since Mayweather left. If all it takes is beating a David Diaz fighter 1 division up from the one you've been in...
For beating B- David Diaz? This win is nothing but a tune up, if you had your P4P #1 vacant prior to the Diaz fight, this should have little...
Cotto is very exciting, Pac is boring and Pavlik is very boring with his overall sloppyness.
