Good posts Seamus. I'd take Calzaghe over Hopkins and Toney prime for prime. Calzaghe raised his game against his better opponents and, if he'd...
I voted Roy simply because of the way he was peerless for well over a decade and because his opposition isn't as bad as a lot of people make out....
I quite like Froch but I agree he mouths off a bit too much. I believe Dirrell deserved a close decision against Froch, as did Kessler. In other...
In my opinion Jones is somewhat greater than Hopkins still. If you compare the best 20 wins of each fighter against the other, Roy takes it. The...
Fair point. Pacman was impressive in the 2nd Marquez fight and did fight a very disciplined and yet still aggressive fight. I genuinely felt...
Favourite memories of fights I watched from ringside were probably Calzaghe's performances against Kessler and Mitchell - both very good to...
Nobody can deny that Manny has stepped it up since the second Marquez fight and done some pretty special things in the ring. But the two Marquez...
Wouldn't it be amazing if, after this seemingly ridiculous thread, Haye really did halt Klitschko within 3 rounds? I would love for this to...
Yep. I'm glad to see the poll results are fair. Calzaghe beat Hopkins fair and square in the ring - I had it to Joe by a single point - but...
Roy Jones is my favourite of the four listed here by far and IMO had the best skills of all these guys in a p4p sense - up to and including the...
1. Trinidad 2. Tarver 3. Pascal II 4. Pavlik 5. Johnson I don't care for Hopkins much as a person but his longevity and career-best wins in the...
Sergio Martinez is a very classy boxer but I think he needs to give Pacman a bit more credit. Considering how small his frame is and how he's come...
Interesting thread this one. Roy Jones, Hagler and Robinson are three of my all-time favourite fighters so it's tough for me to be unbiased here....
Tough fight to call this one but if we're talking about the Tyson that KO'd Holmes in 4 rounds then I make it a 60-40 fight in Tyson's favour....
Can't wait for July 2nd. It's going to be very interesting, especially the first 4 rounds when I believe Haye has his only chance of victory. I'm...
