Do Greb's newspaper decision fights that went the distance have ANY impact on how you rank him all time? If so, how?
Let's see how he responds. If ND bouts that go the distance do impact how he ranks the 2 x fighters involved, let's see how and on what basis? If...
All newspapers, including 4 from Buffalo, scored Greb vs Levinsky 1 to Greb. How does this fight impact how you rank both fighters from an...
Oh Pug, stop with this Hyderabad analysis, will ya? I'll fetch my coat....
You've got it. There are instances of where Greb rematched fighters, because whilst the majority of newspapers scored for him, one did not, and...
Official judges scored Lewis vs Holyfield 1 a draw. The "newspaper decision" was/would have been that Lewis won. Which do you consider correct and...
As I've already explained to you, you're wrong that fighters weren't concerned as to how the newspapers scored it. If they couldn't score the KO,...
Excluding active fighters (Canelo may get in somewhere in the bottom half of the top 10 when he's career has finished), for me it's something...
Imo: ATG's - Walker, Tunney, Loughran x 4, M.Gibbons x 2, T. Gibbons x 2, Dillon, Norfolk, Flowers and Rosenbloom. Borderline ATGs - Jeff Smith...
We're going round in circles. Again, I have different views to you on the relevance newspaper decisions have on ATG rankings, as I've already...
My pick for the most underrated, or at least underappreciated champion/titelest in history, is Horacio Accavallo. On a scale balancing quality of...
Again, I have different views on this subject than you, and that's fine, to be candid, the relevance you place on newspaper decisions to your ATG...
Clearly, I disagree. Fighters were acutely aware that human beings were paid to watch their fights and give their opinion on who won, just that it...
Yeah, your view on the legitimacy of newspaper decisions is one of the core reasons you rate Greb differently to the majority (based on the survey...
There is that, but I also consider an ATG list, based on fighters achievements, who they beat and lost to, how and when, to be distinct from an...
