This is one of the main reasons I disagree with the P4P ranking we have at the present.... the whole concept has changed.... when SRR was named...
P4P Ranking Well, if you understand the P4P ranking as a list that shows 10 boxers from different weight classes (any of them) who at the moment...
I quoted you because you talked about resumes, you give more importance to resumes whe it comes to P4P rankings and I wanted to show you that...
All what I have been doing is giving you examples about the P4P system and why I disagree with it. I had to bring the Mayorga example just as a...
I know what I am talking about. You mentioned the word RESUME, I am talking about the same. I told you what resume means. To make it easy for...
Lance, I said before that I don't believe in a P4P ranking, but what you are saying makes sense too. My problem is with the wording and what they...
1- I just gave you one example. There are many cases like that. 2- You are still talking about resume, but at the same time you are only...
You nailed it. :good The whole concept is hypothetical. In order to prove it in the ring they would have to fight each other, but they don't....
No, it doesn't. You said that "a B fighter can look very skilled against tomato cans but would look horrible against the elite". I just showed you...
Eventhough I don't believe in a p4p ranking, I would say that probably, that's the best way to measure it.
Wrong, Mayorga (almost no skill according to many) beat Forrest a great boxer, with great skills and on top of that, winner of the boxer of the...
And how do you determine who is best in a P4P sense if they never fight eachother? What makes you think (for example) that someone's victory over...
Wrong... it has to do with the fact that you and many others believe in that ****. Why do you care about the P4P ranking if in reality means nothing?
I understand what you are saying but that doesn't justify the claim that being linear is being the best. I think those fans who think that way...
Champs make the title, and not the other way around. I could be the WBO champ and be the best in my division. There are many boxers in history...
