I forgot the third option where fighters are lineal until death or they lose, but you can still start a new lineage What does no-retirement look...
TLDR: It's not a popularity contest. I'm just pointing out the lack of consistency. And it's a mess! But, sure, I might start a thread on classic...
Chisora is shot to bits. He isn't making it through this one. He barely made it to 10 rounds with his good friend Washington carrying him through...
Fiar enough, Lewis |R-2003| Vitali |R-2012| Wlad (2013) > Fury > Usyk (2024~ By the way you mentioned that you try to align with the historians...
What was your start point?
To be honest I don't really see much difference when the challenger is the obvious A side in the situations under discussion. For example, 1)...
I mean surely we only need to defer to historians for time periods we're not living through and subjects we don't have an interest in. Historians...
I think you are down playing an inconvenient truth by saying "Some casuals". Vitali for years was considered the H2H monster of the two. He was...
I suppose as a concept it has its roots in the days of gladiatorial combat, royal lineage, and the game of thrones. Man fighting man, brother...
LOL Not my problem if people get into their emotions over that. Besides, I don't necessarily believe it to be the case, I'm just pointing out...
It sounds an awful lot like you believe in D. ;) So, what is the argument for C but not having Joshua as champion? Whether or not people like that...
That's messy too as you acknowledge Chagaev was WBA champion in recess. Chagaev was also a last minute replacement for Haye (3 weeks notice I...
It is Choose Your Poison regarding Lineal after Lewis: You believe: (A) that Lewis retired the lineage, and Undisputed created a new lineage O...
You are correct, there is a clear double standard being applied to retirements. They are trying to say they don't recognize Vitali because Lewis...
Problem 1 Something seems off about ignoring Vitali in 2003 but installing Wlad in 2009 based on #1 v #3... 2003 Vitali (#1) v Sanders (#3) Byrd...
