Scar, would you be able to determine when did he achieve that status. Do you think that a boxer who has merits to be in HOF can lose that...
Please don't misunderstand me. I asked you for the list to see your criteria, your personal opinion. I am more interested in poster opinions...
Yes, you can find the same situation in a partcular division, but there is a big difference and that is that belts are won in the ring and...
Good work guys. I just want to add that the problem with the P4P list is a big one. Very difficult to set the criteria(s) for the purpose of...
I am not really sold with Taylor, He defeated Nard but I wasn't impressed, The young lion did not impressed me. I think this time he's going to lose.
What's your pick? Can you tell us when did he achieve both status? Exitement is great and I love it, but that doesn't take you to the HOF.
I respect your opinion, but there is a big difference. Morales losing his next ten fights would be like Gatti losing his next ten fights, but if...
Can you please tell me the 49 boxers that would be ahead of him?
If he loses his next four fights would you still consider him for the HOF?
Woud you vote for him as Hall of Famer now? When do you think he achieved that? Would you consider him as an ATG now?
IMO Soto and Valero are not great boxers. I think the thoughest fights for him are Guzman and Marquez. Do you think that he has done enough to...
Would you consider him in the HOF if he had lost to EM the third time they fought?
Can you tell us when did he achieve that?
Is it possible to determine now when he actually did it? Boxers are eligible (if they qualify) for the HOF after 5 years of their retirement....
It is kind of difficult to determine right now who the best ww is. IMO they would have to fight each other and then we can say this is the best...
