Mcgirt takes this via descision. Chavez just wasnt Chavez at Welterweight.
:rofl:rofl:rofl Thats brilliant
Jay Nady is one of the worst referees in boxing, he does a **** job in almost every fight and the fact that he may have been there means **** all...
+ 1
If we're going to go through all the post prime stuff we can include Whitaker losing to Tito, and we can also include Chavez's wins over Meldrick...
Chavez - Limon, Lockridge, Taylor, Randall, Parisi, Lopez, Camacho, Rosario, Ramirez, R Mayweather X 2, Drew with former lightweight champ Miguel...
I'm pretty sure Nunn was contracted to fight the winner of eubank - benn 2. But there was nothing in the contract about a draw! :patsch :patsch
I havent argued that Chavez should be placed ahead of Whitaker. I have argued that he has the better resume. I do feel that Chavez COULD have...
Chavez was past his prime there are no ifs or buts about it. The fact that Chavez was stopped on cuts in his first fight with Oscar despite being...
The second Chavez randall fight was very close and in my eyes Chavez was up by a point. We dont need to go back over the Whitaker fight as we all...
ernesto marcel beat alexis arguello and then just retired at the age of 25
i'm actually just re watching that first mcgirt fight, this is one of Whitakers closer encounters and im currently rescoring it, but it's your...
If you say he won those fights. I personally feel that De la hoya beat him, but the fact is he was well past his prime so you cant count it...
you two have drifted away from the discussion :L its interestiong to see how many people believe Whitaker achieved more, he really didnt! I can...
No way is Whitaker in the top 10 i'm afraid. He doesnt have the resume, end of discussion.
