Kilbane? Kid McCoy? McFadden? Lavigne? Saldivar too maybe? For some reason Winstone seems more popular in this board. Not without reason I'd say.
:lol: We don't even use his name anymore. I've already spent my weekly quota so I'm not gonna say anything. It is true though.
True. Pretty good post. Missed it. But in Walcott's defense, he might have won the title in his very first shot. But then again, the way leading...
Your post points exactly what I was getting at. I even thought about throwing a 40s generation comparison but I thought it would make the thread...
That's why I asked how easy it is to evaluate the depth of their records. Jeff for example punctuated some lame performances with some pretty...
True. How the hell the HW that broke through the color line (and with a foot to the door for that matter) would get near the title if he hadn't...
It came up after that top uncrowned MWs thread. Most specifically between Ketchell and Greb. Mike Gibbons, Jimmy Clabby, Frank Klaus, Jeff...
This is a pretty good list. Just not sure about the counter ability of Benitez and Locche. Wouldn't say great. Pretty good, but not great.
Yep was gonna say that. Argüello - master counter puncher with good defense. Locche - surreal defense and good counter ability. Louis good...
Oh, I never meant you. You weren't making a case for Dempsey anyway, if I got you right. You were talking about how these inaccuracies can be...
OK I admit that those spotty records might give major problems when measuring older fighter like Fitz, or Wilde or Jackson or the guys you...
You mean Dick? Actually thinking again most of the more famous Tigers worth a mention. Dick included (no pun intended).
klompton dropped a killer list in the uncrowned MW thread. All except Gibbons (and even Gibbons to some extent) are UR to some extent I think....
I know. And if he deserves the benefit of the doubt based on that fine sieve line of thought so does everybody with no name fighters in their...
I think he's pointing out the possible inaccuracy in his opponents' records. I don't think anybody would make case for Dempsey based on some...
