I never went in circles, I have stuck to the same argument. I am not comparing Ali to Smith, what makes you even think that? I am just comparing...
You have contradicted yourself now. It was you who first stated that the physical peak isn't the same as the prime which is the best run of the...
It is not mental gymnastics when you can support an argument with examples and evidence. If we take the best run of a fighter as prime, then we...
You are repeating the same thing over and over again. You have a totally misguided definition of prime. I will make it clear for you. Prime of a...
If you are talking about pre-Louis, it has to be Jack Johnson. If it is post-Liston, there is Ken Norton. Kenny beat Ali, Quarry and Young.
Again, you are speaking words that I did not utter. I never talked about absolute peak at all. I said that Bonecrusher's prime began with the...
The reason why bonecrusher did not have the same privileges as Joshua is because he was never as good as Joshua. And this is why he ended up...
Pretty fair rating if you ask me.
While I agree that Louis has the best HW resume prior to winning the title, I am not sure about the 'unquestionably' part since he had lost to...
How are my examples irrelevant? I said Joshua was 15 fights old when he fought Charles Martin. By the logic given by you, Joshua was a '15 fight...
You don't need to wait until you experience the best patch of your career to reach your prime. Archie Moore once stated that Charley Burley was...
I said Smith and Berbick being in their primes is debatable. I did not dismiss the possibility entirely. Calling Smith a novice by mentioning that...
1. Read my post again - I said that Berbick, Williams and Smith being in their prime is debatable. I did not say they were past their primes. In...
1. I assume that this was written in response to my post. Please note that I used the word 'prime' and not 'in good shape'. And this is the reason...
Carl Williams: Holmes was past his prime when he faced Williams. Tyson was in his prime. Williams was in his prime when he faced Holmes. With...
