If he retires after Castillo 1 and doesn't face Mayweather he retires with one loss and wins over Gainer, Castillo, Freitas, Casamayor etc. I...
Potential and actual accomplishments are often very difficult Obviously Usyk hurt his pro legacy by turning pro far too late but he's also hurt...
His physique is strongly indicative of ped use and he had steroids shipped to his address under the name Evan Fields Presumably we are allowed to...
Holyfield was clearly on peds for much of his career? Should we throw out all his wins post 1992 Given rampant per use one would think it would...
Had Corrales retired earlier and not shared an era with Mayweather certainly some people would argue he was an atg. The Mayweather beat down and...
Mayweather has a massive advantage over Usyk in terms of depth though with more than twice as many contenders beaten
For many of his newspaper wins there isn't any controversy over who won and we have multiple sources reporting on his fights. Moreover it's...
Miske was over light heavyweight for much of his career and scored his best wins at that weight so not a light heavyweight by the standards of his...
Lots of fighters don't face mandatories. Canelo feels he's paid his dues and is entitled to take easy fights after a decade of fighting the best....
Mike wasn't a light heavyweight as he fought extensively at heavyweight and has wins over top heavyweights. If Miske is a light heavyweight so is...
Canelo taking easy fights when past prime and in the twilight of his career seems of little relevance. Lots of guys do that. Benavidez is hardly...
If Firpo was a manufactured hype job wouldn't one expect Dempsey to dominate from start to finish?
Tucker also beat Norris and McCall who were likely top 10 heavyweights at the time he beat them Still a poor resume but not quite as bad as some...
Where's the evidence for this version being better than the prior version who lost to Ferguson?
Louis overcame massive weight deficits vs Carnera and Baer. Usyk just beat Fury despite a 5 inch height difference
