Who wins over 12
The thing about Joshua is he missed out on so many of his contemporaries that it seems impossible to rate him even in the context of his own era....
People would be more forgiving of Joshuas losses had he cleaned out his era and fought more big names. If there was a good resume to go along...
When did Bowe become elite SHW? He didn't accomplish enough to make the grade in my book and in shape was about the same size as Foreman and...
Furys clearly better than anyone Vitali beat by a hefty margin. What's the rationale for picking Vitali? I should think Fury was better than...
The Kabayel/Ruiz winner will probably have a case for being number 2 of the era unless Fury does more Also Dubois if he beats Parker
Bert Whitehurst made it past 7 twice. Liston is the guy with 3 stoppage losses despite fighting much smaller men
Brewster fought poor opposition pre Wlad. That might account for not rating highly but it doesn't seem like a reflection of his ability. During...
I don't feel it's a compelling argument to begin with because if nobody will fight you it's hard to rise in the rankings in the first place....
His era overlaps with Pacquiao. What's the case for putting him ahead of Pacquiao
How does one reconcile Bowe being gifted with his spectacular lack of accomplishments outside the Holyfield trilogy? If beating Holyfield in and...
Lewis ledger is overrated in my view. You can argue that guys like Byrd and Povetkin were on par with anyone Lewis beat given Holyfield was faded...
Lack of notable wins can be due to not landing big fights rather than lack of ability. Hard to have a good resume if the top guys won't fight...
Ring ratings are often wrong and probably badly underrated both Brewster and Sanders. Sanders quickly faded from contention following his loss to...
Under what criteria would you put Calzaghe ahead of Pacquiao because I don't see how Calzaghe has an edge?
