No, not really. Cotto was considerably closer to actually losing against Judah and Corley than Mayweather ever was.
***(continued from the previous post)*** No, even if I accepted your relative assessments of these wins (which I dont), you excluded Ali, Louis...
As I said to OLD FOGEY, Tyson and Lewis are more or less equal in my rankings. I generally put Tyson one space ahead of Lewis because I tend to...
:huh That wasn't Woddy's argument.
Well, the Tyson-above-Lewis thing deserves a little asterisk. Tyson is one spot ahead of Lewis (#12), and that's by the hairs of his...
If you read the first post of mine which you quoted in context, you’ll see that I was responding to a post by Mendoza in which he argues...
You don't seem to understand my criteria here. The losses you're going after Dempsey and Johnson for here were, for the most part, in fights that...
WBC, IBF and WBA rankings do not count. If we allowed that kind of thing in our discussion, we'd have to count the Fabio Moli knockout as a win...
As you say, Ali and Louis beat more contenders than Lewis did; in addition, Johnson, Dempsey and Holmes all had around the same number of wins...
Frankly, although I like Cotto and I don't much like Mayweather, Mayweather deserves this. Cotto beat a Judah who was already a Mayweather...
A win over a great champion like Calzaghe at 43 years old, on top of all Hopkins' other achievements, would propel him into the top 20 greatest...
No, it wasn't a knockdown. Vitali was hurt by a hard counter shot from Sanders, but his falling over was the result of rubbery legs and a push...
I disagree. The 12 men I have above Lewis are, again, Ali, Louis, Foreman, Marciano, Frazier, Holmes, Dempsey, Jeffries, Johnson, Holyfield,...
