Like I stated in the other thread Mayweather is generally a little bit overrated and is if at all a boderline ATG. If Mosley werer to beat him,...
Theses facts speak for him, but on the other side you got to consider: - He spent a few years fighting weak competition which was tolerated by...
Well, if he comes back and beats a couple elite welterweight division, that would change a lot in my book. I would rank Mayweather as a sure lock...
-The boxers you name are very good (not great except perhaps DH)fighters but Mayweather retired very early. The O does not mean much if you...
He once was, but boxing is no more blood because he did not fight the many challenges in the welterwwight division. He has become more and more of...
He is TOP 50. Probably around 30-50th place.
First of all, Mayweather fought only one time at 154 and that against a guy who started out several weight classes below. Then, Mayweather did...
I am quite surprised so many people were offended by this thread.Did not know the mayweather fan club was so big on ESB. Again, I maintain that...
Well, I support JT so I am really not in position to give you credible answer. There is one thing though. I admire the fact that a man starting...
Well, you made some nice points and I respect your opinion. - longivity, the fact that he retired at a young age, challenges left in the...
Sorry but this is just garbage You say so. ATG lists have always been subjective because different criterias are used. I made some valid points...
My statement is not ridicoulous at all or driven by hate. People are confusing ATG with HOF status all the time. Boxers like ODH, Joe Calzaghe...
My statement is not ridicoulous at all. People are confusing ATG with HOF status all the time. Boxers like ODH, Joe Calzaghe are no sure lock...
A few questions dumbass: 1) Name me one ATG that retired at the age of 30 leaving so many challenges behind him? 2) If Mayweather lost to...
It is no hater thread. To me, Mayweather is a HOF but no ATG. Mayweather was not around long enough and left many challenges behind him he did...
