I can appreciate both sides of the story here. Hagler was top notch, yet he never moved up (as many posters would have loved him to). Duran is a...
I see Pep and Armstrong. But... You'd pick Jofre to beat Salvador at Feather?
My thoughts exactly. ie: (at the specified weight), I think he would beat most below him on my list, and he would lose to most below him. Best way...
I like your style. Takes some balls to rate current fighters in an all-time list. Many fans (and I admit the knowledge base of the guys on this...
These are my precise thoughts, to a tee.
This makes me feel a bit better for allowing Kovalev to squeeze into my top 50 all time LHW (was worried I was overrating him). But top 5, I can't...
I know his career was all too short. So we can't track his possible decline. So, prime for prime, how many of history's top featherweights beat...
I'm going to be controversial here, and say number 9. But I'm fully aware that I rate Spinks too low. Feel like I'm missing something. I get the...
A 10-2 type beat down, methinks, in favour of Tszyu.
Foreman (and Marciano) threads always prompt too many insults here, for some reason. Anyway... I think Dempsey loses to young Foreman. I think...
You're right. I was thinking of Barkley at middle. That was a few years later. I stand corrected.
SuzyQ is on fire in this thread. Fair play. For better or for worse, I never knew a lot of that stuff. Glad to learn, so thanks for the evidence...
Regarding my list, I simply believe that, at 160lb, Fitz beats the majority of people below him, and loses to the majority of people above him....
When it comes to levels, I think Dempsey is a borderline top ten heavy (and has an argument with Langford as being possibly the greatest cruiser...
Barkley always looked big at the weight.
