Scar, I actually have my round score and notes from that fight to hand: “Round 1: Harada 10 Caraballo 9 (Caraballo was winning the round and...
Looks pretty good to me. I can think of some alternative names for some divisions instead of the names you’ve picked but I wouldn’t argue to...
The third option in the poll should probably be ‘Draw’. ‘It was a close fight’ isn’t exclusive of the first two options. In terms of the fight...
This is actually the scenario I laid out earlier in the thread, George. Fighter A dominates Fighter B for almost the entire round, giving Fighter...
Yeah, I agree - I think the absolute best Fighter A can do is a 10-10 even with their previous dominance. Personally, I feel it gives the...
I think it was a close fight even though I had Tommy ahead. The big determiner for me is how you score rounds 5 and 12. Rounds 3 and 11 are...
Here is a scenario for you which I’d be interested to see your views on scoring it: Fighter A batters Figter B from pillar to post for 2 minutes...
The 10 point must system has its flaws, for sure but I think there’s a degree of leeway and applying common sense too. For example, it is not...
If it’s the last 50 years that would make it 1973 onwards - on that basis I’m not sure Saldivar would have a place given his best work happened...
Damn, I’d forgotten about Thomas Hearns and Michael Spinks.
Yes. I didn’t realise that was how the deduction was marked up in practice. In my own scorecards, I just factor the deduction into my round score...
Yes, I have seen plenty of fights play out that way and have been surprised at the end by my own scoring because it didn’t tally with my overall...
Easily done! Whitaker is far from being a personal favourite of mine but his record is undeniable, of course.
I’d probably switch out Holyfield for Pernell Whitaker.
Greatest ‘performance’ by a UK boxer? [MEDIA]
