Who wins over 12
The argument about poor competition could be applied to other middleweights that are frequently rated highly. Hagler competition doesn't seem...
What if Wilder lands first? Foremans not known for his amazing defense
If we are going to question Makhmudovs power based on not knocking out good fighters than the same should be true of Wilder. He hasn't kayoed...
Since his amateur stoppage losses Joyce has faced bigger punchers and held up fine so it seems reasonable to question the relevance of those...
I think this is potentially a competitive fight H2H. The guys Dempsey fought by in large were no bigger than today's light heavyweights and not...
Foreman never beat anyone over 235 and never once faced a big weight deficit in his career. He also never beat a top 10 heavyweight who...
Joyce has already accomplished more than Williams and Jones did. I would put his win over Parker above anything they accomplished, probably...
Joyce looked to be in good shape vs Dubois at 258. I don't see how the weight is useless. And Joyce certainly seems far more capable than the...
I have to disagree on Bakole. He is on a good win streak and coming off some good performances. He has been more impressive of late than Wallin...
I think if one counts Ortiz as a live opponent for Wilder than you have to count Parker for Joshua. Both have pretty awful resumes but were...
Arguing someone in invisible to the public or unknown etc doesn't seem like a good argument. Prior to beating Klitschko Fury had an absolutely...
I don't think ratings are very useful either given the top guys don't generally face each and fans use guesswork. I would have probably put Whyte...
Part of the idea behind ratings is ranking people on what they do in their own era. Tyson Holyfield and Lewis are all basically from the same era...
