Careful with "rediculous" claims. Few people would seriously argue that other sports can not be compared to boxing at all. Most would acknowledge...
Two points on this. First, because it is a sport without tangible performance records, no one will EVER agree that one era is the best of all...
Agree to disagree. I just don't see that. It's against human experience for training etc to deteriorate in the manner you suggest. And the size...
The only absurd one is you, since you can't recognize added weight has a benefit, not just a detriment, and that the extent to which that matters...
As Kiwi suggested, I remove the lower weights from this equation because they are tied down by size, it makes other comparisons to other sports...
Then you have a small mind that goes by convention and not reason. I suppose you think young George Foreman would have done better in every single...
Good job of quantifying the potential arguments kiwi.
Agree to disagree. It makes a huge difference when on fighter relies on a style that has a proven track record against larger fighters, and the...
Your argument is still textbook absurd. I left out stamina because I don't see how it would be a significant factor in this fight. I give logic,...
Did you read my post? He didn't get an opportunity to beat Lewis after the first fight. He inarguably did alot more in fight to deserve the...
Thanks for the reply. I'm about logically quantifying arguments though. By saying the top twenty of an earlier era beats the top twenty of this...
Amazing this is so controversial. What would have happened if Schmeling and Frazier never gave Louis and Ali rematches? Those fights were...
Im a big guy and if I have a bias, it's for the big guys. But I try to be fair about it. Either way, it's better than the racial bias that alot of...
And yet other, tangible record sports that are less popular now than before (discuss etc) have seen records broken and the same body size...
You can always tell who has an agenda by the certainty they show. I've said it's certainly possible Lennox, who is one of my all time favorite...
