Reminds me of what Marvis Frazier needed.
I'd definitely consider his opposition superior to guys like Ruddock, Golota, or past prime Holyfield.
I only really read the post I responded to, and I said what I said because you were asking if it was a different discussion, but the blanket...
I respect your opinion. You think he's able to beat an '83 Greg Page?
I'd pick Holmes most of the time, the only things that you can put against him are when he was past his best, and he fought better competition...
He has the closest chance against him, for sure. If you want to put him over Bonecrusher, that's fine. I put Bonecrusher at 10 because despite his...
Weren't you just asking if that was worth a different discussion?
When talking with broad terms like "better" with no clarification, more evidence is better, and therefore, competition is relevant.
I think the fact that Coetzee is remembered says enough, even if people can't list off any of his performances. He had his place in boxing...
Remember that this is a head to head list. He would not win against any of the top men in the game.
The wins were impressive, but not impressive enough to put him head to head against anybody else in the business. He had a cuts win against Young,...
It's not so much Holmes getting caught in the ropes, but Holmes being enticed out of retirement with two weeks to train against a prime Mike, I...
He was undefeated for a reason.
When your father's a piston and your mother's a windmill, you have to punch like that.
Just goes to show how much performance on both sides matter.
