After revalutations the last few days I've settled on this. Which I will defend against any haters. Keeping it at 30, 40 was just unnecessary. And...
You know what? I think you're right. Not about the first point, I'm going to stay with my rule that if a boxer has a fight scheduled he's active...
Derevyanchenko, I know he's an eye-opener on my list, but the guy's brilliant. Others call him a 'future' p4p but because I rate potential I'm...
Jacobs, I rate him highly for his overall talent, skillset, and evolved ring smarts since his earlier fights. But I rate him above specifically...
I moved Gonzalez and Kovalev below Mikey, after their recent fights. Coltaine made good points about why Gonzalez should remain high. I know you...
This thread needs to be dumped in the Things a Casual Would Say thread, because Horn 'beats Crawford because he beat the current version of...
Nice doubleheader. Jarrett Hurd is not that good. Not top level anyway. Not a great boxer, not that fast, doesn't hit that hard. Trout's got this....
Should I have included Trout over anyone?
Because with the announced fight whatever you think of it he's active, and based on how he looked against Berto he's still the best boxer in the...
I think I'm happy with this. Spent too much time with this the last two days, so won't tinker more for now anyway. 1. Mayweather 2. Lomachenko 3....
I haven't directly addressed Golovkin. My justification is implied in other comments. My top 5 are my creme de la creme elite. In addition to...
Continued good comments, you make this hard for me. Most of us now may be underrating Gonzalez from how he's looked since moving to 115. I am...
I think Hunter's performance was overrated a bit. He was tough, was pretty tricky, but he didn't win more than only a couple early rounds and Usyk...
Taking the changes I referred to into account, here's my adjusted p4p. I've added Santa Cruz, and also Gary Russell above him. And, ugh, to make...
Ok, first Roman Gonzalez. I had him top 5 p4p way before most did, but I also never annointed him number 1 when Mayweather retired. I earlier had...
