What make's Tyson's for example THAT much better?
More or less the answer is that a lot of guys are roughly on the same level. Guys like Holyfield, Frazier,Tyson etc. don't have much separating...
I'm waiting for someone to ask a question like where Jimmy Bivins, Freddie Miller, Pascual Perez, Tiger Flowers, Stanley Ketchel, Battling Nelson,...
That's a good question. It's not non-pareil, but it arguably should be.
True, I'd take that over an outclassing by Buster Douglas though :good
Actually let me correct that, I don't think Dempsey was really any more dominant than the likes of Tyson. He might of had a slightly longer peak,...
Dominance.
Quite possibly. But he was hardly Mr. consistency, even at his best.. I wouldn't have been shocked if he put up a worse effort in his prime than...
All of those guys you mentioned had something which DLH didn't, and that's dominance.
Whitaker's around 20th on my p4p list. I thought he edged DLH, but holding your own with a guy on the cusp of a top 100 is a pretty good effort...
He arguably belongs. There's a few guys there that Evander could be interchangeable with, but if you look at the names on my list, there's no...
Cheers:good My main justification for having Marcel over Evander is the level of dominance that Marcel displayed during his prime. Evander has a...
McDicky turned back the clock for that one :D
Of course. Anytime you want to tell me why Oscar is better than 75 to 80% of the guys listed there (and who those guys are), I'll be here to...
Harry Greb, Sugar Ray Robinson, Ezzard Charles, Benny Leonard, Sam Langford, Henry Armstrong, Roberto Duran,...
