Results through 19 votes: 1. Gonzalez 157 2. Ward 149 3. Lomachenko 144 4. Kovalev 141 5. Golovkin 94 6. Rigondeaux 89 7. Crawford 86 8. Pacquiao...
Hard to call, but Shabransky I think has the style advantage. Barrera will be hard to land too many on, but Shabransky has the edge in range,...
Mikey Garcia, or the guy who was outboxed by Mauricio Herrera?
You have to have a proper top 10 for your vote to be counted!
Results through 13 posts: Gonzalez 113 Lomachenko 105 Ward 99 Kovalev 92 Golovkin 63 Crawford 61 Rigondeaux 59 Canelo 32 Pacquiao 27 Inoue 16...
Lara and maybe Andrade have the skill of Williams, but I think have more confidence and experience to adjust. Williams was slightly outboxing...
What have you guys got? I'm hoping for at least 100 lists by the end of the month to get a good sample size. Considering how many believe Kovalev...
You've put up a pretty good defence for Canelo. But no one here is saying Canelo isn't a top 10 p4p because of his opposition. He's not making our...
Let's start with his knockout of Lucian Bute... [MEDIA]
Yes, and this is even more pointless because it isn't a better way to show who the best boxers are. Lists are just good nerdy fun :) And I do...
Setting a 155 limit did make a mockery of the mw title, but I agree with you that Cotto was the one who made it a problem because he insisted on...
I agree with you that the point of p4p is comparing ability. I only think opposition matters if a fighter hasn't faced anyone good enough to bring...
Maybe he's partly saying who you beat lately matters, but mostly that Canelo should have to beat an elite, skilled guy his own size before we...
Because he has slow feet and struggled with movers like Lara and Trout, and Khan for the first few rounds. Because a top p4p fighter should be...
I'll put the cumulative top 10 and total results in the first post. What I've got for myself is... 1. Lomachenko 2. Rigondeaux 3. Gonzalez 4....
