"Walcott's biggest wins were over Charles" But Walcott beat lots of guys who were much bigger than Charles. Charles was simply better than the...
"I don't understand what nationality has to do with this." Nothing, really. It is just that the judges who are scoring this fight for Vitali are...
Vitali's inept performance against the largely stationary Byrd, missing somewhere between 75% to 80% of his punches to a man relying totally on...
Scoring boxing is subjective, and you SAW the fight you are describing. But two of the three judges were American. Harold Lederman (whose score...
one--I scored the fight 7 to 2 in rounds for Vitali. That comes out to the same as the three judges, plus Lederman on the tape of the fight, with...
"while trying to jab his own way in on the massive V. K." Why do you assume that Walcott would fight Vitali's fight and get into a jabbing...
One argument which has been made on this thread which I have been thinking about and really disagree with is that Schmeling's biggest win is...
Many of the exciting John Ruiz fights are being overlooked. For the clinching cognoscenti, Ruiz fights are summa cum laude. One sees every type...
About a "prime" Joe Louis. You are talking to the wrong man here. I agree with you. There are posters playing games with prime as well as with...
"You watched a completely different fight to me" Fair enough. It has been quite a while since I watched this fight so I will try to watch it...
A Fitz weighing somewhere in the 170's puts him at about the same size as Conn, and Conn gave a prime Louis a terrific fight. (There is a claim...
You mean Vitali wreaks his shoulder and quits. I have seen this fight in its entirety. Vitali doesn't have a career win and it is hard to rate...
"It comes down to how you rate the era" Not exactly. Jeff was much better overall in his era than Max was in his. To rate Max ahead, you must...
In a finish fight, I like Willard. In a 12 rounder, I have to take Valuev. I don't see that Willard has the technique to beat him, and who...
I agree that Vitali (or Wlad) will see moves they never have. I also think the size differential will prove too much to overcome for Walcott....
