Sorry buddy but once again you are spouting nonsense that isnt grounded in fact. First of all, the idea that a champion cashed in on his title by...
Soldier Buck wasnt a HW. You are correct. There would have been no reason to rank Greb as a HW even up until the second Flowers title fight in...
I dont believe Greb was ever rated by the ring at HW due to the reasons I and McGrain outlined above.
Wait wait wait. Lets back up here. Johnson lost his title in 1915. Between 1915 and 1919 Willard fought once. ONCE. During that time period WW1...
What does Joe Louis, who fought two generations later, have to do with this argument? Is your argument that because Louis (who has a far better...
Because Ring didnt list fighters in more than one weight division and since Greb was champion of the MW division he couldnt be rated in the HW...
Whatever man, you are arguing out of both sides of your mouth. Boxing isnt a popularity contest. It doesnt matter what you think the public wanted...
Thats the punch that woke Joe up and resulted in Eddie getting knocked out the following round.
You know who was on the publics radar? The guy who never got a title shot...
In May 1920 Greb signed a contract to fight Dempsey in Buffalo. Dempsey was to get $50,000 (the same he got paid for Miske) and Greb was to get...
I dont get your point. Gibbons was second behind Wills in that UNOFFICIAL poll. Greb beat Gibbons that night. If Greb was so far and away behind...
That point might hold water except for tje inconvenient fact that Rickard signed a promoted a hw title elimination match between greb and gibbons,...
The war may not have been his fault but to pretend he earned a title shot with nothing in the interim is silly. His win over Gunboat came on a...
You are arguing "could have" i am arguing whether they did or not. You are pretending steroids exploded on the boxing scene like a bomb in the...
His win over gunboat smith was a joke and called by even his most ardent admirers inconclusive. So you listed three fights, all of which took...
