How about Mayweather over Pacquiao? Pacquiao is a greater fighter than Spence, past his prime but so was Spence and Pacquiao went on to achieve...
I wonder if this is because welterweight doesn't have many strong performances on film or people aren't used to listing them but fights that were...
Is Honeyghan over Curry in this discussion?
If we're going to be ranking performances specifically and not just the win itself, film is needed imo. EDIT: And Griffith vs Tiger wasn't at...
Do you think either Pacquiao or Mayweather have a performance that's a good contender here?
It's a shame we don't have film of Robinson vs Gavilan 1 & 2. It's a good question, off the top of my head I wanna say probably not but I would...
Lmao
It was a genuine question, not sure why you're so grumpy.
Ok I understand what you mean now. At the end of the day, Wlad never beat Vitali and I can't say someone cleared a division when they didn't beat...
Not entirely sure what you mean by this. He had a claim to the lineal title makes sense to me, having a "lineal claim" to all the belts doesn't....
When you say goat do you mean cruiserweight, heavyweight or p4p? I think the greatest cruiserweight is defendable, I think the other two claims...
Maybe reread that post. "People who haven't become undisputed generally aren't going to be people who cleared their division" is not the same...
https://www.boxingforum24.com/threads/what-excites-you-the-most-about-the-future-of-boxing.737633/ Don't know if this helps or just makes things...
Again goalposts are being moved. We went from "boxing experts" to "American media" There's overlap but those are not the exact same thing. EDIT:...
You moved the goalpost. We went from the fighter dominating the division being non-American to all the top contenders needing to be non-American.
