Moore was my number 21. What position do you feel he deserves, according to the parameters?
I certainly should consider him. I guess guys who peaked at 215, I just didn't think about. Where does he slot in, when he's that light?
Thank you. I'll look into Baer's performances at lighter poundage. As for the others... Yep, considered them, alongside the Sharkeys, Fitzsimmons,...
Yep, Frazier could possibly be in contention. For those who fought well at around 200lb, they could slot in just fine. 205lb, yeah probably. 210lb...
Thank you to everyone who contributed to my silly thread. Sorry to all the guys who didn't like it. I like these fantasy lists. I think some of...
Gipsy Daniels? Had a lot of losses, but wasn't even a heavyweight yet KO'd Schmeling in a round.
1. Liston 2. Ketchel 3. Wilde 4. Langford 5. Gans 6. Fitzsimmons 7. Duran 8. Sanchez 9. Frazier 10. Hearns 11. Choynski 12. Foreman 13. Arguello...
Great fight. Napoles is literally the only person I pick over Duran at LWW. Napoles Duran I Williams Armstrong McFarland
Lennox Lewis a true all-time top heavy. Part of this is due to his physique, but nonetheless he is a great. Weaknesses when compared to others?...
I think this bout has been covered in previous threads. Have a search. You'll find some replies from much more knowledgeable posters than myself....
Thank you @George Crowcroft. As stated before, I rate more on h2h (75%) than resume (25%). But this is difficult. My poor attempt: Tier I Klaus,...
I'm trying my hand at a top 100 middles list. The following candidates may not be in everyone's top 25, or even 50. But please try your hand at...
1. Liston 2. Ketchel 3. Wilde 4. Langford 5. Gans 6. Fitzsimmons 7. Duran 8. Sanchez 9. Hearns 10. Frazier 11. Choynski 12. Foreman 13. Arguello...
Sometimes when I compare eras, I think it fairest to do a halfway house, rather than giving complete advantage regarding rules, refs, gloves, etc....
What would be Harry Greb's absolute peak fighting weight, if he needed to weigh in within 24 hours of fighting time, and had, say... 1960s rules...
