It’s very close.
It depends what exactly you’re looking for.
I’m going to say it’s Andre though, but only by a tiny margin.
It was a great achievement, but obviously there’s been greater.
That’s because he’s in his 40’s and he’s winding down.
You can’t expect anything else at this stage of his career.
How could GG have the best legacy ever?
Are you thinking of Sven Ottke?
He didn’t duck Dariusz.
A legacy is what you leave behind.
Are you asking which of the above is the most respected, or garners less criticism?
A legacy is based on a...
Of course he lost muscle you donut.
What planet are you on?
Where is he?
Is he on a ban?
There’s been some great threads since I’ve been a member.
It’s almost 9 years since I joined.
There’s one that sticks out from all of the...
There was no evidence of him possessing a glass jaw.
Possessing a glass jaw and not possessing a good chin are 2 different things.
If you look...
AJ has never been slept, but neither was Roy until he was 35 and he’d had over 50 fights.
It was also in his 3rd weight from a guy weighing 180...
There’s a world of difference between saying someone didn’t have a good chin, and saying that someone had a glass jaw.
If Roy had’ve had a glass...
Do you think that the shot landed by Johnson was harder than the one landed by Tarver?
Even though he couldn’t continue, he jumped back...
People don’t claim that Roy was drained beyond Tarver.
We’ve discussed this before.
Again, Mackie Shilstone has said that burning muscle can...
He took good shots in his prime.
Tarver hit him with a bomb. A perfectly executed left hand. That shot would probably have knocked out most of...
Because he was mostly knocked out by big punchers, 3 weight divisions up, after taking flush shots when past his best and vulnerable. And his...
Anybody who picks Roy is an idiot.
You’ve still not answered my question.
You think it was a draw?
Look, in terms of ability, Joe was not as gifted as Pea.
Pea’s skill level was higher.
Yes, Joe was a great fighter....
Yeah, after Oscar had waited him out for as long as it was possible.
We know you hate GG, but stop being ridiculous.
Canelo and Oscar enjoyed beating Cotto to be labelled as the MW champ. But then when it was time...
You need to be objective here.
GG didn’t get the opportunity to unify all of the belts in the same way that Canelo did.
Cotto would fight...
Nobody cared about the rubber match.
My original point, was that Whittaker fought Chavez and should have been awarded the victory. And I...