Toney by late stoppage. A guy like Froch is tailor made for Toney's style at 168. Go back and look at the fights where guys come forward against Toney, specifically Iran Barkley and Charles Williams.
Toney by a WIDE, CLEAR unanimous decision. Wow! Froch demolishes Bute and all of a sudden he beats the prime versions of Jones, Calzaghe, Toney, Ward and Larry Merchant 50 years younger all on the same night.
Nah against Toney I see Froch boxing from outside. If he tried coming at James he would learn real quick he aint beating James like that after eating a couple of counters.