Thanks for the courteous response Joe. My list is no more valid than yours. To be fair, looking at our respective top 10's relatively briefly, the same names mostly appear somewhere on each other's lists, even if in different orders, which is only to be expected. I think the only guys in my top 5's that don't appear for you in that decade at all are Tommy Gibbon's in the 1910's (though you have him in the 20's as do I), Ruben Olivares in the 60's and Vicente Saldivar in the 70's. Equally, if you have time at any point to glance over mine (see Page 3) and think I've missed out anyone obvious, it would be much appreciated if you let me know. It's quite possible I've forgotten to consider a deserving boxer.