1910 vs. 1960. I matched the 1960 Ring magazine annual ratings from 1-5, vs. what could be viewed as the 1910 annual ratings. Which group do you think takes it under the following rule set: 15 rounds, 20 x 20 ring, 10 point must system, liberal ref for fouls/clinching. Each seed much face each other. Johnson vs. Liston Langford vs. Johansson Jeannette vs. Machen McVey vs. Folley Jeff Clark vs Cooper
How is Liston #1 in 1960? The title was passing between Patterson and Johansson at that time. Liston wasn't #1 until '62.
I would be fairly confident of Langford beating Johansen, McVea beating Folley, and Clark beating Cooper. The rest of the matches could go either way. I therfore give the edge to 1910.