Make it for 12 rounds for the WBA title which they both held at one point respectively. Smith was a little bit bigger but not much . Both had decent chins but not iron ones either. Both possessed punching power. Coetzee was a bit more mobile and skilled. What do you think ?
I'm going with Boney. I think he had the better chin and Coetzee had a history of fading in fights. Smiths relentless pressure would eventually crack Gerrie as his stamina wanes. I like Smith by KO around 10-12 rounds.