Whitaker/Basilio is a ****ing awesome match-up. Can't believe I've never seen that one before. That's worthy of its own thread.
But yeah, DLH over Napoles is embarassing. Not just a gulf in class there, but a stand-up text-book type like Oscar is exactly the kind of opponent you don't want to throw in there with Mantequilla.
Yeah, they're different levels of technician. The scenario they've used for Oscar winning is the most viable one though. Still, i take Napoles to school him.
DeLa Hoya, Canzoneri and McGovern are a bit over the top for me ... interesting how over rated Oscar was ... I read a similar one where they picked him over Ray Leonard at 147.
Does any one have the rest of the match ups? Not relly a summary of it, but a list of who wins what Ali ud Louis Robinsion Ud SRL Lewis ko 1 Marciano ete.
Oscar was a great fighter, but he gets schooled by Mantequilla. Different classes of fighter, wasn't Napoles only stopped on cuts once? Cuts were his weakness but you can't just assume that he would be cut up.
Tunney over Holy I feel because Tunneys a better technition and his toughness is underated. Moore-Foster is too close for me to call. Whittaker UD Basillio Napoles clear UD over Oscar. Arguello I believe takes Canz on points in a tough close fight.
Yey i have the rest of the matchups, ill post a thread later on,but i cant post there whole analysis its do damn long. :think Or maybe i can if its one fight. Thought many of you would rather here a summary on a lot of the fights than the whole anaylisis on one fight.