3 great fighters. 3 great fights. You choose- MAYWEATHER, CALZAGHE, PRYOR

Calzaghe would have lost for sure IMO, Floyd would have won with relative ease, and the Pryor/Benitez is a toss up.

Assuming a victory in all three I'd say JC would have benefited most from his fight.
Floyd would have been upgraded a fair bit as people really thought Kostya was great (look how much credit Hatton got for beating a somewhat worn down KZ) . Benitez, though an all-time great, is not and was not in the publics mind enough to make Pryors legacy much more than it is, though personally i think it would have been an awesome win if he could have pulled it off.

 

problem with calzaghe is that he never had any weight on the world stage - so being reflective of his career has to lay blame at his feet.

he did it consciously so let's not give him dues he hasn't earnt (or even tried to).

floyd-tszyu wasn't that far from happening imo.

tszyu-oscar was being talked about before tszyu lost for the first time, so both tose match-ups went up in smke after that.

i never followed boxing (strangely enough) while i was involved in it - it was always just some fun and a way to keep sharp for me, so i really can't comment on the prior-benitez fight.

 

I feel Mayweather outpoints tszyu. I feel the fight would be all about floyd keeping a long way from tszyu's right

 

agreed. on that part i have no doubt floyd would have mowed down tszyu.

and i'm australian!

 

The real interesting match-up for Jones-Calzaghe would not have been at LHW, where clearly Jones would have been too powerful, but at SMW, where Calzaghe has always belonged. Jones, assuming he could make the weight, would likely still win, but it would have been a real battle.

 

i dont agree although calzaghe is a talented fighter.

calzaghe has never beaten a proven world class fighter in his prime.

it's indicative of british fighters over recent years and, until ricky hatton came along and bucked the trend, it's always been the achilles heel of most british fighters.

 

Kostya would of destoryed mayweather even mayweathers skills dont surplas kostya was far the most feared and on e of the best in the junior welter, flyod wouldnt of dared take the fight neither would de la hoya! so Kostya tszyu to land straight rights on mayweather and a round 8 ko!

 

its not going to happen.

tszyu lost the oscar fight on his own, and i can't see floyd losing too much sleep with tszyu.

 

Pryor beating Benitez would of done wonder's for his resume.

 

Floyd skools Tszyu

Jones KO's Calzaghe

Pryor Destroys Benitez

 

Calzaghe beating Roy would have been huge, not as much to other way around.

Tszyu and Mayweather had a lot to gain from each other. Thats another division Mayweather could have ruled and been the man at, with a win against one of the best to ever lace them up at 140.

Pryor beating Benitez would have been big for him but with Wilfredo only just loosing would have taken some gloss of the win.

Im to tired to make sense right now.

 

Mayweather by close but not debatable decision over Tszyu.

Gotta lean towards RJJ over JC on pts but wouldnt be shocked at a Calzaghe win on pts.

Pryor by razor thin decision over Benitez but could easily be vice versa.

All great competitive matches - anyone who says different doesnt know **** IMHO (just waiting for all the JC haters to hit out with nonsense like Roy KO2 Joe, haha.)