3 questions about Wilder

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Golota1, Apr 5, 2026.


  1. Golota1

    Golota1 New Member Full Member

    34
    47
    Mar 16, 2026
    1. Where do you rank Derek Chisora among the best Deontay's wins?

    2. How did this win change your perception of current versio of current version of Wilder - do you think he isn't as shot as most people thought him to be after his last couple of losses?

    3. How would Wilder vs Chisora fight play out if they have faced each other in their respective primes?
     
  2. The Professor

    The Professor Socialist Ring Leader Staff Member

    31,223
    22,782
    Sep 29, 2008
    1. #3 or 4, depending on how you rate Stiverne

    2. I've never thought he was as "shot" as some claimed, he's just not that good

    2. Similarly. A close, debatable decision
     
  3. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Active Member Full Member

    678
    720
    Oct 17, 2020
    He was both shot, and not that good.

    you don't get knocked out like that and it doesn't affect you
     
    swagdelfadeel likes this.
  4. KernowWarrior

    KernowWarrior Bob Fitzsimmons much bigger brother. Full Member

    3,251
    3,659
    Jul 12, 2012
    1. Where do you rank Derek Chisora among the best Deontay's wins?
    I take the view that the win could be viewed as one of the most important to him, as he proved he was not gun shy, albeit the 'gun' was not once what it was.

    2. How did this win change your perception of current versio of current version of Wilder - do you think he isn't as shot as most people thought him to be after his last couple of losses?
    Well i had him down prior to the fight as going to beat Chisora, so not changed my perception, however despite being pleased to see Wilder showed others he is not gun shy, it does not change my wish for him to hang up the mitts, go out on a win.


    3. How would Wilder vs Chisora fight play out if they have faced each other in their respective primes?
    I think Mr Wilder would have had his 2 seconds of luck and got KO or TKO win, his right hand had a definite soporific effect when it landed, Chisoras pressure could well have won him the day, but i will stick with a Wilder win.
     
  5. GGGfans

    GGGfans Active Member Full Member

    1,261
    1,838
    Dec 27, 2017
    1- 4th behind Ortiz I-II and Helenius
    2- Wilder is shot
    3- Probably Wilder by KO
     
    Redbeard7 likes this.
  6. catchwtboxing

    catchwtboxing Loyal Member

    31,429
    42,288
    Jul 4, 2014
    1. It's #1. Stivern was a guy who gets beat by Demetrice King, and Ortiz has a shockingly think resume, marred by the fact that his own best win, Thompson, involved a PEDs bust. This was it, and never mind that Chisora is old, because so is Wilder.

    2. He's shot. He can still enjoy more fights against fellow declined fighters- Whyte, Joshua, Ruiz...but he's not contending any more.

    3. Who knows? Probably similar to last night. But are clumsy...Wilder has the bigger power but Chisora is a guy who will try to bully you and load up with right and left hooks. Messy brawl at any point in their careers.
     
  7. Rick’s Piano

    Rick’s Piano Member Full Member

    257
    386
    Jan 24, 2025
    1. its a top 3 win of his career. partly for the lack of good wins under wilders belt but also taking into consideration where both fighters are at. both slowed down but chisora was considered to have more left in the tank coming off two of his best wins.

    2. he looked better than i expected at this point but still sloppy, slower and maybe the powers leaving him. i dont think he'll be able to be as competitive against less shot fighters but he defo looked better than i expected. I will say i did leave with more respect for his chin. ate shots and gave them right back.

    3. in there prime? both faster and stronger but both more reckless. I reckon wilder gets him out of there still.
     
  8. Redbeard7

    Redbeard7 Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,228
    3,226
    Oct 9, 2022
    1. It's his 4th best win, after Ortiz x2 and Stiverne 1

    2. Wilder is shot, more shot than Chisora, which was reflected by him being the underdog

    3. Probably Wilder KO, similar to Haye-Chisora

    The win is also improved by Chisora being the home fighter and having the ref on his side.
     
    Last edited: Apr 5, 2026
  9. DubbleJab

    DubbleJab Member Full Member

    126
    162
    Apr 4, 2026
    Not sure I follow?

    Chisora has been knocked out and hurt WAY more times than Wilder, hasn't stopped him walking forward to every opponent he has faced though has it? Just like it didn't stop him last night, at the age of 42, continuing to just walk forward over and over despite not having his legs underneath him most of the fight.

    Wilder probably has more heart than we realise. But he's never been allowed to show it, because he's never been allowed to fight contenders.
     
  10. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Active Member Full Member

    678
    720
    Oct 17, 2020
    Wilder was not that good to begin with. He was allowed to succeed in an enviorment where he had low level of competition outside of AJ, Fury at the time. He was never really tested outside of fighting Ranked Ortiz which wasn't all that much. Once he started to step up his competiiton after getting KOed he started to fight those guys he was ducking and that went horribly.

    So it is not that he was shot last night. He was, but he never was that good to begin with. The division is at a historical low point which is why Usyk is allowed to dominate in the first place. He wins his fights off of conditioning more than his boxing skills,which is why his fights don't end up as 9-3 fights like Crawford does,because his skill alone is not what is winning him those fights.

    Wilder was a fighter in a weak era that managed to hold a belt hostage who was shot after getting blown out by Fury and his competition got tougher so he got more exposed, but he would have lost to those guys anyway,because he was not good to begin with and won fights off of athletisim, and he wasn't even all that athleticely gifted either i'd say.
     
    Smokin Bert likes this.
  11. Serge

    Serge Ginger Dracula Staff Member

    83,916
    139,336
    Jul 21, 2009
    Chisora is 42 y/o and has taken way more punishment and has way more miles on his odometer than The Dosser does. Let's not forget he fought Belly x 3 and took an absolutely pounding of him in the rematch and trilogy too

    Usyk
    Belly x 3
    Vitali
    Haye
    J-Park x 2
    Kabayel
    Pulev x 2
    Whyte x 2
    Bjg Joe Joyce
    Takam
    Wallin
    Helenius

    I won't include binmen like Szpilka, Washinton, Scott because they're trash

    vs

    Belly x 3
    J-Park
    Big Bang
    Ortiz x 2
    Stiverne x 2

    And Chisora coming in the heaviest of career at 266lbs and even worse at 42 y/o made things much easier for The Dosser because Chisora was moving and punching like an obese sloth underwater with 50lb weights on each arm and you could see his punches coming from a mile away. The Dosser was able to time him repeatedly when he was coming in, evade his telegraphed shots, block them, or take the sting off them and actually give the impression he possessed some boxing skills because of how slow and telegraphed his shots were.

    Even the Chisora of a few fights ago would've knocked him out and even if this version of Chisora had coming in 10lbs lighter it would've made a huge difference

    The Dosser clearly has a lot more left than Chisora does and his losses to Belly, J-Park and Big Bang have more to do with the level of opponent he was facing ie. top 10 world class fighters who actually possess skills and not cherrypicked low or no skill bus conductors, street vendors, and crab fishermen which is what he forged a career off beating


    Let's not forget he was losing every round in his biggest wins vs one of the few world class fighters with skills he fought prior to then in both his fights vs Ortiz up until he clumped Ortiz into submission with his rabbit punching masterpiece in their first fight and his big right hand ironed him out in the rematch

    Prime Chisora knocks his ass out of that I'm very confident
     
  12. Joeywill

    Joeywill Boxing Addict Full Member

    4,307
    3,143
    Aug 2, 2021
    1) I think Chisora is Wilders 5th best win
    Ortiz 2x
    Stiverne first time
    Braezele

    2)Didnt change it that much and yes I dont thinks hes as shot as I did going into the fight

    3)Wilder Kos Derek Chisora in round 8.
     
  13. NoNeck

    NoNeck Pugilist Specialist

    29,430
    20,038
    Apr 3, 2012
    1. Ortiz
    2. Ortiz
    3. Stiverne
    4. Breazeale
    5. Spzilka
    6. Chisora
    7. Arreola (probably better than Chisora, but Chisora was on a nice run leading into the fight)

    2. unchanged

    3. like the Haye fight, but shorter
     
    Joeywill likes this.
  14. bailey

    bailey Loyal Member Full Member

    40,337
    3,430
    Dec 11, 2009
    I guess people will view whichever way they choose to suit their point of view

    One view could be that they were both past their best, so reasonably evenly matched, though Chisora has fought overall at a higher level imo

    Another view could be that Wilder was facing someone who possibly has a better resume than anyone else he has beaten

    Maybe it's a bit of both

    I would possibly have it as his 5th best win, behind the 2 Ortiz wins, Stiverne and Breazeale

    A question to everyone -
    Chisora had lost 13 times previously
    Do all those 13 wins other opponents had rank higher than Wilders win?
     
  15. JusABoxinFan

    JusABoxinFan Active Member Full Member

    1,287
    1,149
    Apr 20, 2022
    1. It's top 3.....simply because Wilder doesn't have an elite resume. Chisora was never elite in my eyes.

    2. Wilder isn't shot, he's just not very talented. He showcase that even this weekend. Wilder was exposed by Ortiz, then Fury capitalized on it. This win doesn't change what's already on the timeline for me.

    3. Similar....probably more exciting, but I think it probably ends the same way.