***A New, Fair System for Judging P4P***

It was merely a KD. We were merely being surprised by your hit, then we got back up and pwned you ever since, save in the humour department.

 

- all his posts have been low blows. Officials outta remove him from the ring.

 

Sure Wlad is dominating the HW division, but guys in the p4p rankings are dominating MULTIPLE divisions. Not only that, they also dont get KD in every fight, doesnt look that vulnerable, beats elites and dont get KTFO by journeyman's. Not hating on Wlad, one of my favs...but gotta be objective here. Wlad is not as dominant as people make him out to be...seing as he hasnt even managed to unify the HW yet after all these years and a crap HW crop it is too.

 

Instead of doing all of that - I just go off someone else's pound for pound list - like the Ring or Dan Rafeal's ESPN P4P list. These are some of the better ones that I've seen out there.

 

Yes, we are whining about what a Manfredo-wannabe is doing in a fight amongst us elites .

But thanks for the correction in my broken translator, didn't realize it was spelled the same way as in danish.

 

Hard for a HW to dominate in multiple divisions, unless they didn't start as such.

 

Butter- and Babybean comes to mind . True US fighters.

 

It's "easy" to become champ in different weight classes, if there is only 5 lbs from weight class to weight class. Wlad would have to amputate one of his legs and and one of his arms to make 200 lbs.

 

Its Vice versa, you damn foreigner.

 

Although P4P is a fun discussion it makes me wonder why so much weight is given to this fantasy. I no of no other major sport where pound for pound is discussed.. Best P4P; golfer, football player, basketball player, tennis player, marathon runner, shotputter, discuss thrower etc. Why not?

The other fantasy in boxing that really needs to be addressed is prime vs. prime fantasy time "capsule" matches like Marciano vs. Lewis, Robinson vs. Leonard etc. This is especially true in the heavy weight division. Ex. If Louis were to battle Lewis in a fantasy fighti, in their primes, and put the time capule year @ 1965, J Louis would be 2" taller and 15 lbs. heavier while L Lewis would be 2" shorter and 15 lbs. lighter. Why? Research tells us humans have been growing taller and heavier dramatically over the past. In the last 60 years the average height of the Dutch has increased by several inches!!!

So Jack Johnson would be about 6'5" today, Marciano 6'1" 220, etc...

 

It's called the danes, unless you are referring to pastry.