A question to Roy Jones Jnr fans about his win over J Toney

You cant answer and this sadly is why posters like yourself get upset with posters like myself.
I ask feasible questions and due to some being fanboys, dont want to answer. I havent knocked anyone or discredited anyone or a win, but asked a question. This is where posters like yourself look a joke when you cant answer and refuse to answer. You show yourself up with that.
You tried to change the subject to Froch, who I am a fan of and was saying watch how I will do this, but I have no problem with being honest and it doesnt make me any less of a fan with any fighter. I dont try and change the facts to suit. Thats what people who cant answer tend to try and do.

At least now, we can draw a line under this thread for you, with the knowledge that you couldnt answer and could never call anyone a fanboy etc

 

Well this question has caused Blizzy to leave this thread

This content is protected

If Toney had not have got the decisions in some of the close fights leading up to the Jones fight, would the Jones win, have been viewed as such a big win?

Yes or No?

 

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php?title=Fight:5864

This is why I say posters cannot answer a simple question

This content is protected

If Toney had not have got the decisions in some of the close fights leading up to the Jones fight, would the Jones win, have been viewed as such a big win?

Yes or No?

 

It is the original question, explained slightly differently.
The original question

the slightly altered for someone like yourself

Do you really think that is so different?

As for your answer, you dont think the win would be viewed as greatly if he had a loss to Sosa, Williams, Johnson, McCallum and Tiberi, which shows what I wrote which was the power of having an 0.

You struggled to answer and now the win doesnt look as good when you remove Boxrec

 

I have plenty to go now as you yourself have admitted that without boxrec it wouldnt have been considered as big a win . These posters who you think have trampled me have been trampled by you now . Well done

 

You have done it again and shown that boxrec and hype sells to you

 

I will ask another just for you, as you have humoured me throughout.

Which of these fights leading up to the Jones fight, do you feel Toney won?

- drawn with S Williams
- been taken to a SD by M Sosa
- was taken to a SD by R Johnson
- drawn with M McCallum
- had a SD with Tiberi where some felt he lost
- a MDec with McCallum

 

Not disagreeing? Not sure what you are going on about here?
I felt he fought Kessler and Ward to close fights but lost to both, but felt he won the rematch with Kessler. I felt he edged Dirrell but wouldnt have argued had it gone the other way.
Why are you bringing up Froch again? I dont disagree with alot of what you wrote here :huh

 

Absolutely.
He seemed to desperately want to not answer for a while, like many others on here. In fairness, although he didnt want to answer, at least he finally did. Many others just hurl an insult and run off the thread and pretend there has never been such a question.
Interesting that someone who has been so defensive, actually feels it wouldnt have been viewed as big a win if not for Toneys 0