A Tournament full of OLD, SHOT, PAST THEIR PRIME FIGHTERS...WHO WINS?

Taylor or jones jr

 

Jermain has the most left in the tank of any of these guys, it would also depend on the draws, but I think Jermain as it stands today is the best fighter on this list.

 

How? he is past his prime. His game depended on reflexes. Thats why he has seen the most sudden and dramatic decline.

I agree that Casamayor would take it based on skills alone. He or Wright.
Although this is only because we are saying they would all make 160. Casamayor is a smaller guy but would everything stay the same based on his skills i see him taking it.

 

Of course not Mayorga has the most solid chin ever in the game. He has never been KOd. haha

Obviously the guy is exaggerating but Casamayor in these mythical match ups would destroy Mayorga.

 

I would put money on Jermain Taylor to beat Sergio Martinez today. He ain't shot, or old.

 

:huh mayorgas been kod multiple times

 

Agreed!

I took Winky for the record.. Taylor/ Jones close seconds....

Miranda vs Mayorga would be entertaining!

 

Roy jones got KO'd when he cut 25 llbs to fight tarver . . . whats gonna happen when he cuts another 20? hed be getting KOd by peter freaking manfredo!

 

I have been on record with this idea as well, I think he would be a legitimate threat to Martinez and has the best chance of beating him.

 

Winky maybe.

 

I'd actually love this. I would think the top seeds would be

1. Roy
2. Jermain Taylor
3. Winky4.
4. Mosley

another good fight to add would be Lacy vs Miranda