Adam Smith needs to replace himself!!!!

Discussion in 'British Boxing Forum' started by smithshaun, Aug 23, 2020.

  1. alpo1

    alpo1 Active Member banned Full Member

    Dec 10, 2005
    I remember in the 00s everyone was turning on legends like Larry Merchant, makes you think wtf were people thinking looking back. Even the crap commentators from that era like Lennox are miles better than the drivel we get nowadays.
  2. Dragon Punch

    Dragon Punch Boxing Addict Full Member

    Sep 15, 2012
    With the jokers on Sky nowadays, it makes me miss the days of Dark and Watt/McClory
  3. N17

    N17 Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    Feb 16, 2013
    Exactly, I don't think we realised how bad it could actually get.

    I don't think boxing fans ask for much, we just want fair referees, fair judges and fair commentary.. just FAIR.
    Wizbit1013 and Here's Johnny like this.
  4. Here's Johnny

    Here's Johnny Well-Known Member Full Member

    Jan 18, 2015
    I know Jim Watt went a bit off the boil but it always felt like a proper fight when he was commentating. If I hear his voice even now, it could be 6 in the morning and I suddenly feel the urge to order a pizza and pour myself a lager. It’s mad how a brain is wired.
  5. Turpins chin

    Turpins chin New Member Full Member

    Aug 29, 2019
    With Smith, I can never forgive or forget the bomber comment.
  6. N17

    N17 Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    Feb 16, 2013

    :risas3: Still one of my favourite commentary moments, it was just so horrific.
    Glenn McKrory and Turpins chin like this.

    BEATDOWNZ Boxing Addict Full Member

    Nov 30, 2014
    So they're clueless? Listen to them.

    Biased as hell? Yes. Know more about the game than anyone on here? Also yes.

    BEATDOWNZ Boxing Addict Full Member

    Nov 30, 2014

    I like Bellew. He's top drawer. But he's nearly CRYING when a MR fighter loses.

    These guys are supposed to be fair, but they're not. Too pally, pally.
    im sparticus and N17 like this.

    BEATDOWNZ Boxing Addict Full Member

    Nov 30, 2014

    The lines were blurred ages ago with the "jobs for the boys' when our stars retire.
    Clarence Gianni and N17 like this.
  10. Dragon Punch

    Dragon Punch Boxing Addict Full Member

    Sep 15, 2012
    Realistically we are going to be stuck with the current set up. I think the best we can therefore hope for (certainly for big fights) is a return to the 3 person set up with Smith, Paulie and Froch/Macklin. Paulie is excellent at keeping the Matchroom bias in check and gives great technical breakdowns.
  11. chatty

    chatty Boxing Addict Full Member

    Aug 18, 2009
    I said this a few weeks back but its clear as day that the commentators/pundits are forced to go along with roleplaying for Sky.

    Sky have there method of commentary that they want everybody to follow. When Macklin started he was really good as were Barker, Lee and others but within a few months they are all Sky robots, overly biased, shills.

    Only one who doesnt really follow suit is Froch but at the same time he doesnt do any homework, gets the fighters wrong and often seems like he has no clue of whats on the card so that helps nothing.
    im sparticus, N17 and BEATDOWNZ like this.
  12. tee_birch

    tee_birch Well-Known Member Full Member

    Jul 6, 2014
    I’m the same with sky. Part of me the retired pros have a continued revenue stream but the likes of Macklin offer no insight at all. “I’ve seen this fella train, he’s a cracking lads and all the boys at the gym wouldn’t have a bad word to say about him.” While he’s being beat pillar to post for 5 rounds while Smith has him 3-2 up
    Clarence Gianni and BEATDOWNZ like this.
  13. rezzer

    rezzer Member Full Member

    Feb 11, 2009
    It looks like Froch has been binned by Sky. I dont think it's his discrepancies as a commentator, more likely it's to do with him believing that the earth is flat and his interesting views on immigration, ironic when you consider his family is of Polish origin.
    BEATDOWNZ and chatty like this.
  14. Ted Spoon

    Ted Spoon Well-Known Member Full Member

    Sep 10, 2005
    One of the biggest faults with the Sky Sports team is their awful habit or tying to force a narrative i.e. "And you just get the feeling..." rather than simply calling the action. Last night they all went with the script that Whyte had won every minute of the fight before the KO.

    Irritating and unprofessional.

    Adam Smith seems to bring the worst out in everyone. Unless Paulie's there it degenerates into cheer-leading - Barker, Macklin, Bellew, Froch - whoever's 'working', they all merge into one uninformative voice.

    I appreciate Smith's enthusiasm for the sport but it probably would be better if he worked behind scenes.
  15. Furious

    Furious Active Member Full Member

    Nov 2, 2017
    Exactly - they have a narrative for each fight. The one last night was ‘Povetkin was a top fighter, he’s visibly slowed but still a very respectable win for Whyte. Whyte will have to adjust on the fly to deal with such a seasoned operator but eventually will pull through’

    They basically repeated lines to reinforce that ad nauseam all fight. Ties in nicely to that ‘learning on the job’ line they pin to Whyte. It’s all so contrived and pre-meditated.
    Clarence Gianni and rezzer like this.