After Money beats Mosley, Pacquiao and let's say Berto is he top 3 all time great?

I say that would be impressive but the range in heights of these guys make me think twice about just shooting him to the top . Mosley is still a live opp. but come on if we are just looking at the margo fight then yes Mosley is a beast . Now they are close to the same size age tarnishes the match up a little , Then Pac age not the big concern but they height will be a factor all though Pac's reach is good for his height . Berto wet behind the ears and not tested yet . But add Paul Williams too the mix i dont care if its a sd . if Floyd can beat Mosley ,Pac and Williams then id have him in the top 10 welters for sure .

 

If he beats PW, Margarito and Cotto, he cracks my top 15.

Yes, Cotto who albeit already been koed 2X, is stylistically a difficult fight for PBF. You have to overwhelm Cotto to stop him from beating you up. PBF will not out jab Cotto and Cotto will bomb away when PBF stays on the rope and shoulder roll.

 

You have to be borderline ******ed to even ask this question.

 

He is already top 50 3 big wins like that would be top 30 I think a quick way to get even more ATG recognition would be to move up and beat Pavlik

 

You are my favorite alt/nuthugger

 

oh my...p4p #1 nuthugger no doubt.

 

None of your choices were suitable. If he beats Mosley and then Pacquiao, I'd put him in the top 25. On the other hand, if Pacquiao beats Clottey and then Mayweather, I'd put him in the top 15.

 

If Mayweather wins those three fights...then he's Top15 IMO.

If Pacquiao beats Clottey and then Mayweather....then he's Top10.

But Mayweather/Pacquiao will never happen because Pac is a *****.

 

So, let me get this right...if Mayweather beats Mosley, Pacquiao, and Berto, he is top 15 to you, but all Pacquiao has to do is beat Clottey and Mayweather to be in your top 10? I agree, but I don't see how you can say that in one breath, then call Pac a ***** in the other. If he is such a *****, what has he done to warrant being 2 fights away from your top 10 ATG?

 

Good perspective.

 

top 10 imo...it all depends on what those fitghters do now too

 

If he beat Manny and Shane w/berto sprinkeled in he'd be in the top 20 for sure....some may say he's top 10, but not many. Definitely he'll jump from where he presently is in the top ATG ranks.

 

he'd be in the top20 but outside the top10.

spots 11-49 are missing from this poll

 

Jesus Christ, get his **** out of your mouth.

 

how...manny was able to get top 10 with a miguel win..floyd would have beaten a top 10 in manny so that mixed with victoreis over a young fighter like berto (undefeated) and a tough and talented mosley would get him in the top 10 imo...thats a lot of "ifs" though your right