SCOTT HARRISON Record: 25-2-2(14) Top 5 wins: Michael Brodie KO4, Walter Estrada KO5, Manuel Medina TKO11, Wayne McCullough W12, Juan Pablo Chacon W12 World title history: WBO featherweight champion 2002-03, 03-06 ALEX ARTHUR Record: 26-2(19) Best wins: Koba Gogoladze TKO10, Willie Limond KO8, Boris Sinitsin W12, Sergey Gulyakevich WTD7, Sergio Palomo TKO5 World title history: WBO superfeatherweight champion (interim 07-08, then full champion May-Sep 08) Who do you have higher p4p and why?
harrison easily, he fought the better fighters and was a two-time champion, still doesnt stop him from being a ***** though.
Harrison by a country mile. His career was far better and more accomplished despite it being premature. I dont think AA will achieve much more than he has already.
I always preferred Arthur as a person (though he has gone down in my estimation after the post fight Cook rubbish) but this answer is undeniably Scott Harrison, a man whom I considered top 5 in the World at FW at his best.
Scott Harrison by far the better pfp. No contest. Arthur would have been ko'd inside 3 rounds imo. :hi:
it's a no brainer scott harrison by far.arthurs never been that good.he should be attracting as much stick as khan on thse boards,but with all the focus on khan he appears to be getting an easy ride.
Why exactly should he be getting as much stick as Khan? He doesn't run his mouth ALL the time and get huge bucks for doing **** all. He seems a nice enough guy with it.
Harrison. Arthur is more a bit more skillfull but Harrison was formidable in the ring, it is a pity the 'Celtic weakness' stunted his career.
Scott Harrison and its not even close. Harrison was one of my favourite British fighters of recent times. Alex Arthur as someone put has probably acheived all he is going to, and it seems to me that all the chopping and changing he does concerning trainers is he is trying to find a problem that he will never be able fix and to me thats his talent st world level (or lack of).
i agree he probably is a nice guy,i would think when you strip away all the hyped bull**** he's surrounded with so is young khan.however when you look at alex arthur without ever fighting and beating anyone of real note in terms of world class,he ended up being handed a world title.yet he can't even beat the best of british.flattened by gomez then beaten by cook,haven't seen the fight but some reckon quite comfortably.he even struggled against foster jnr. yet other fighters on here who have achieved infinitely more like calzaghe and hatton attract much more stick.
