All World Class Fighters.................but which one has been most overrated?

calzaghe is top 10 p4p and world class.....but also massively overated imo...has about 5 or 6 wins against fighters who i would say are truly class, and 3 of them are past prime, has shown that he can be knocked down fairly easily at this stage (people may say he is past his prime now, but seeing as he didnt really do anythng good in his prime cant really judge on that), he basically just throws a **** load of punchs, i would pick a world class outsider fighter to beat him any day

 

There is a major, major fail in your first post.

You said there were four major titles. Since when?

 

Are people just voting for Enzo Maccarinelli because of who started the thread?

 

Pavlik and Berto

 

:yep:yep

 

Kessler had a fight with Calzaghe and lost but that wasn't the only thing he lost he lost his confidence and mental touighness has to be questioned. He pulls out of fights with Miranda and says Dawson is too big and is content fighting in Denmark against no-hopers and guys he dwarfs in the ring. His resume isn't that great and is considered the man at 168 by default since Joe left and hasn't really done **** but win a vacant belt.

 

Wow, he sucks and you don't even say why?
Lol, Loser.
Why isn't chad dawson on the list anyway?
He would easily be voted the most IMO.

 

Chad Dawson is a two time title holder at 175 who's trying to fight everyone under the sun at 175 but no one wants to fight him including Calzaghe or Hopkins. If anything he's underrated.:deal

 

Maccarinelli. Not hyped by the most people but I spend more time on this site than any other boxing source and he's the guy I'm most sick of hearing utter fantasies about on here.

 

Berto. We'll see if he deserves the hype this weekend.

 

Who in the hell overates Enzo?? atsch

From the list i'd say Froch, people saying he can knock out proven fighters such as Taylor, Kessler, Bute and even Calzaghe, when the best fighter he has fought is Pascal, who himself is a contender.

 

hmm maybe im being paranoid but i cant help notice that most fighters are british:huh

problem = over hyped/rated is used too much in boxing

solution = bann britain from competeing

 

From what I've seen and of the list to choose from, this was my vote too.:yep

 

:good