Am I outta line with this heavyweight ATG list?

Bowe shouldn't be on that list, IMO. I would have Lennox ahead of Foreman. Patterson a little bit higher. Though Wlad is a bit of a stretch for 13 even though I like him.

 

Klitschkos shouldn't be rated in such lists until their times up, we can't really say as of right now, but I do believe Wladimir will end up top 10, Vitali just missing out.

Lewis clearly should be ahead of Foreman.

 

doesn't look that bad, Bowe isn't top10,

 

As long as Ali is your #1 I will agree

 

Louis too low imo.

 

Bowe and Frazier tied? ...Immensely out of order.

Vitali in there? For what, his wins over Peter? Arreola? You tell me.

 

I have:

1. Ali
2. Louis
3. Holmes
4. Johnson
5. Lewis
6. Marciano
7. Holyfield
8. Tyson
9. Foreman
10. Frazier

 

Bowe deserves it, Holyfield too high, he should be right behind Bowe, and Tyson is too low, ATG list is ranking them at there primes right? Tyson's Prime can't get any higher, but if your judging on overall career, then I guess I could agree.

 

frazier should be ahead of holmes.....tyson ahead of vitali

 

x10

 

An ATG list in my estimation should be ranking fighters according to the following criteria: Resume (50%), Ability (20%), Dominance (20%), and Longevity (10%). On that basis, the notion that Bowe should be higher than Holyfield is beyond ludicrous.

 

Props to the greatest left hooker of all time.

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yATYM20Gl8[/ame]

Also the winner of the FOTC.

ATG bound in my book, without a doubt.