Am I outta line with this heavyweight ATG list?

George Chuvalo is the Greatest Heavyweight of all time.

His two losses to Chris Byrd and past prime Lennox Lewis.

Translates as coming from a lay off to outbox Samuel Peter.

So you think victories over Gomez, Arreola, and Johnson actually give Vitali a case?

**** as always.

 

first thing wrong is that vitali is in the top 10
2nd is that he out ranks holyfield??

Holyfields heavyweight title fights 19
Vitali title fights 7 (we dont count the WBO GARBAGE BELT sorry, vitali vs obed sullivan is not a heavyweight title fight)
kirk johnson
Lewis
Byrd
Danny Williams
Corrie Sanders
Kingpin Johnson
Arreola
JC Gomez

no point naming the "other guys"

holyfields notiable opponents (title fights)
Buster Douglas
mike tyson
mike tyson
george foreman
larry holmes
riddick bowe
riddick bowe
lennox lewis
lennox lewis
Hassim Rahman
Nicolay Valeuv
Bert Cooper
john ruiz
john ruiz
john ruiz
chris byrd

notable opponents NON TITLE
Sultan Ibragimov
Alex Stewart
Alex Stewart
Riddick Bowe
James Toney
Fres Oquendo
Ray Mercer
Pinklon Thomas
Quick Tillis


yeah...that warrants a vitali all time 7 ranking...what a freaking joke man

 

Can't recall ever agreeing with your prior posts .. but on the face of it or a quick glance that's a very good list overall.

 

Uhh... He actually might beat Tyson. Holyfield beat Tyson because he was outslugging him, and clinching, and manhandling him. Marciano hits harder then holyfield and pressures more. You can make the arguement that this isn't a 100% prime tyson, but I see the familar fate because Marciano has the conditioning of holyfield, the chin, the heart, and he hits harder. holyfield is bigger and taller and faster, but that's it.
Yeah.. Marciano would get killed by a prime foreman. Not sure about Frazier though.
keep in mind if this goes by 6 rounds Marciano has all the advantages vs Tyson, and foreman..

 

I Think you Underrated Marciano too much !!! Marciano was a Destroyer in the ring, a Real Warrior with a strong chin and Heart, his Punches was very very hard .You are wrong to Think Marciano have No Chance to Beat The great Boxer belive that !!!

 

"that's it"? :nut

 

you have got to be the dumbest mother ****er ever to post on here
youre a fan boy fairy. you were the type of kid at school who was scared of someone because they were bigger. Vitali isnt even on the same page of an evander holyfield. i just layed it out for you dumbass. youre eyes just cant get off vitalis nuts. 19 world title fights to 7?
tyson, foreman, bowe, lewis, moorer, holmes, mercer,
to obed sullivan, corrie sanders, carlo gomez, sam peter, hasim rahman?
its painful to sit through a boring hugfest, slappy, vitali fight....a guy that big and scared to mix it up. you wont ever see a fight of his on espn classic, i promise.
get a life man and stop being a nut sucker

 

marciano is a guy you cant compare to current guys because of his size. 187 pounds and 5 ft 9.... lets just say he beat everyone from his time...and he fought in a generous time like the klits do now.... look waht the 60s brought...patterson, ali, liston, terrel, chuvalo, wepner, bonevena, frazier
not knocking marciano, he did what he could with what he had

 

Well honestly, how is Holyfield better then Marciano, fighter-wise?
He only has better hand speed, and he's bigger, and taller.
I would honestly pick Marciano over him in a fight.

 

i would pick holyfield over marciano, but wont bash the rock. i just dont think they would even be in the same league. marciano strugled against an old archie moore who had almost 200 fights...and was even knocked down by him. holyfield was a different animal , watch the dokes fight...
it was a different time, marciano would have been a great cruiserweight....or light heavy if he was around now

 

My favourite heavyweight, nice one.

 

I agree with you :yep

 

Not really, primarily because he won 36 of 38 fights by TKO...also, he had a light weight--by the name of Haye-- scared sh*tless and unwilling to fight him.:deal